Ever since I started practising anaesthesia in 1991 fentanyl has been part and parcel of almost every anaesthetic I have given or observed. At the very least 50 – 100 mcg is used to attenuate the airway and cardiovascular response to airway management. More fentanyl can be used for further intraoperative analgesia and sometimes it becomes a total fentanyl affair with PCA continued postoperatively. Even neuraxial anaesthesia usually has fentanyl as part of it.
But it seems this potent µ receptor could be causing underappreciated trouble. The potent lipophilic opioid agonists (fentanyl, remifentanil etc) induce acute opioid tolerance which results in more severe postoperative pain which is more resistant to morphine analgesia.
This phenomenon has been well studied in rats using doses (per body mass) that are far in excess of human clinical practice and it seems it is due to changes that occur in the NMDA and GABA receptor processes.
But even modest clinical doses in humans seem to contribute to this unwanted effect. Sukhani (Anesthesia-Analgesia Nov 1996) compared anaesthesia for gynaecologic laparoscopy with 100mcg fentanyl versus 15 – 30 mg ketoralac without fentanyl. Pain, nausea and time to discharge was longer in the 100 mcg fentanyl group even though this group had lesser intraoperative propofol.
In more contemporaneous techniques, anaesthesia for laparoscopic cholecystectomy was compared by Collard in Anesthesia-Analgesia (Nov 2007). Desflurane anaesthesia was administered with either fentanyl, esmolol or remifentanil. The esmolol group had the superior postoperative course with significantly less need for analgesia and antiemesis and a more rapid discharge. The remifentanil group had the worse outcomes for analgesia, emesis and discharge time. Xuerong et al (Anesth Analg Dec 2008) found higher morphine consumption in abdominal hysterectomy patients who received 3 intravenous doses of 1 mcg/kg of fentanyl with spinal anaesthesia compared to controls and those who also or only received ketamine or lornoxicam.
Remifentanil may not be the wonder “nitrous-oxide killer” after all. The literature now abounds with the effect of remifentanil on morphine tolerance and hyperalgesia and a report of its use for a laparoscopy (Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim. 2008 Jan;55(1):40-2) reports an extreme case of postoperative hyperalgesia.
Morphine, presumably because of its lesser potency and lipophilicity does not cause such a degree of rapid acute tolerance, but of course its tendency to cause PONV still limits in applicability in some situations.
Ketamine seems to counter the acute tolerance of the lipophilic opioids and I wonder if this is what its true analgesic effect is. It may be better avoiding lipophilic opioids altogether and using anaesthetics (including regional anaesthesia and intravenous lignocaine) to anaesthetise and alpha and beta blockers to attenuate haemodynamic stress. Magnesium may be valuable. Perhaps analgesics should be kept in reserve until pain is expressed or soon before pain is expected to be expressed.